Two votes went to Duke -7.5 and one went to Illinois +7.5, the number from the November 16 taping. No. 10 Illinois and No. 5 Duke meet Tuesday, November 17 at 4:00 PM PT / 7:00 PM ET in Durham, NC. The full debate is on the College Basketball Picks: Tuesday 11/17 + Wednesday 11/18 + Thursday 11/19 episode.
Illinois vs Duke Odds
When the guys taped on November 16, Duke sat as a 7.5-point favorite over Illinois, so Illinois backers were getting 7.5 points.
Our Picks
- Ryan Kramer (@KramerCentric): Illinois +7.5
- Sean Green (@SeanTGreen): Duke -7.5
- Colby Dant (@TheColbyD): Duke -7.5
Colby Dant opened the case for Duke. He pointed to the blowout loss to Michigan State and expected a response, and said Illinois is not at 100% with key players dinged up after already losing in Lubbock. To him it was a Duke spot, so he laid the 7.5.
Then the talk turned to the free throw line. The guys noted Illinois was shooting 59.7% from the stripe, while granting it was a four-game sample. They also gave Illinois credit inside, saying the Illini are very good in the paint with a two-point percentage through the roof. Still, a team under 60% at the line heading on the road looked like a smash spot for Duke.
The Illinois case started from that same stat and read it the other way. The argument was that the Illini are underperforming their expected free throw percentage based on past numbers, and most players drift back toward their own percentage over a large sample. The Illinois side also noted the Illini already played a road game, the loss to Texas Tech, so the first true road game angle was off the table, and the Illini were worth taking with the points.
Hear the full breakdown on the College Basketball Picks: Tuesday 11/17 + Wednesday 11/18 + Thursday 11/19 episode, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Watch every game on YouTube, and download the SGPN app at sg.pn/links. See all our College Basketball Picks.
More 11/17-18-19 College Basketball Picks
Boston College vs Harvard
UConn vs Arizona
Seton Hall vs Wisconsin
Oregon vs Oregon State
VCU vs Santa Clara