
Just a few weeks remain in the College Football regular season. Let’s take advantage of these full weeks of football we still have left! Step into the CFB Prop Shop with me as we discover the Week 12 College Football player prop best bets.
Last week was another strong one for the article. Three of our four plays came through. West Virginia’s Michael Hawkins Jr. was the lone player who let us down. Mark Bowman held our system strong and cashed as the lead tight end against the Hoosiers. Jelani Thurman once again did work for the Tar Heels of North Carolina. The tight ends treated us well as Patrick Overmyer went for 116 yards in the Houston Cougars’ loss to Colorado. Let’s see if we can replicate that this week!
Let’s kick things off Friday night as CJ milled, and the Toledo Rockets host the Bowling Green Falcons. Toledo is a massive 16.5-point favorite in this game and for good reason. Toledo is the much better team, and that should lead to a positive game script where they are running the ball late.
Lucky for the Rockets, Bowling Green’s rushing defense is terrible. They rank 116th in the nation in rush yards, allowing 191.9 yards per game. Miller ran for 83 against UMass last week, 135 the week before, and 185 yards on the ground against Western Michigan a few weeks back. I’ll be looking for Miller early and often Friday evening.
Decker DeGraaf Over 15.5 Receiving Yards (-114)
If you are a weekly reader, you knew this play would be in here. We haven’t talked about Decker DeGraaf this season, but we have talked about the tight end playing against Indiana, and we’ve talked about it a lot. Against Minnesota, it was Roman Voss who went for 39 yards. For Michigan, it was Hogan Hansen who hit for us at 34 yards. Nebraska’s Luke Lindenmeyer racked up 45 yards against the Hoosiers. Northwestern’s Luke Dehnicke tore this defense apart for 140 yards on seven catches.
Then last week it was USC’s Mark Bowman with a number set at 30.5. The Trojan crushed the number, racking up 47 yards on six catches. This week, it’s DeGraf who is on our radar. The Washington Huskies 6’4” Junior totaled 68 yards last week against Michigan State. He’s gone over this total in six games in 2026. Trust the system.
Patrick Overmyer Over 63.5 Receiving Yards (-114)
Overmyer was so nice last week, I figured we’d try him twice. Last week his total was set at 44.5 as the Houston Cougars traveled to Boulder, Colorado. He burst out even more than we could have predicted. Overmyer caught nine passes for 116 yards and a touchdown. That’s back-to-back games going over this total and seven times this season.
This week the Cougars get to play against West Virginia. One of the worst overall defenses in all of College Football. Only Colorado State has given up more (56.0) yards per game than the Mountaineers. West Virginia ranks 137th out of 138 teams, allowing their opponents to gain 515.4 yards per game. They are dead last in pass yards allowed (320.8). That sets up very nicely for Overmyer to have a big day.
Jeremiah Smith Over 99.5 Receiving Yards (-114)
Jeremiah Smith has already cemented himself as the best wide receiver to ever play in the Big Ten. Now, he gets to face a beat-up and banged-up Nebraska secondary that’s already allowed some big games this season. Andrew Marshall and Kahmir Prescott are both out for this secondary. On the front end of the Husker defense, stars Owen Chambliss and Jahsear Whittington will also be out.
This is a beat-down Huskers team that is limping into their final two games against their toughest opponents. Illinois’ Collin Dixon showed what can happen against this Huskers defense when a good receiver on a solid team plays them. He caught eight passes for 129 yards on the day. Smith has already gone over this total in six games in 2026, including the last two.
