Redraft Fantasy Football Trade Value Chart – September 2023 Update

Redraft Fantasy Football Trade Value Chart - September 2023 Update

Week 1 of the NFL season is over, and Week 2 is already starting. By now, you’ve already touted how good your draft was. Or perhaps you’re panicking. Either way, you can always improve your team. However, how do you weigh the difference between “player A” and “player B”? Don’t worry; we can help! Our redraft fantasy football trade chart weighs the values of players to give you a little help on what trades may seem evenly weighted.

Or, you can use it to show your league mates why you’re offering a good deal! Either way, we hope it can help you trade your way to success. There have been a couple of changes since our last redraft trade chart, and we will continue to make changes as we always want to keep improving the methodology behind it. Speaking of methodology, let’s talk about that real quick.

The Methodology

What is a trade value chart, you ask? Our methodology takes FantasyPros Rest of Season Rankings and average points per game. After that, consider points above replacement level player and average draft position. Is that it? No, that’s not it! Finally, we tweak the numbers ever so slightly to make sure it all makes sense.

This fantasy football trade value chart is different than the dynasty trade value chart that you can find here. One of the main differences is this solely focuses on fantasy output and change in value rather than age, as the dynasty chart heavily considers.


SGPN Fantasy Football Discord

Old-Fashioned Football YouTube (Fantasy Football + Whiskey Reviews)

September 2023 Redraft Trade Value Chart

betmgm risk free bet

Fantasy Football Redraft Trade Value Chart – September 2023 Update


Player Team Position Trade Value SuperFlex Value Player Team Position Trade Value SuperFlex Value
Patrick Mahomes II KC QB 28 70 Jordan Love GB QB 6 15
Josh Allen BUF QB 21 52 Russell Wilson DEN QB 6 15
Lamar Jackson BAL QB 20 51 Kenny Pickett PIT QB 5 14
Jalen Hurts PHI QB 20 49 Sam Howell WAS QB 4 10
Justin Herbert LAC QB 16 40 Matthew Stafford LAR QB 4 10
Trevor Lawrence JAC QB 16 39 Mac Jones NE QB 3 7
Justin Fields CHI QB 15 38 Jimmy Garoppolo LV QB 1 3
Joe Burrow CIN QB 15 36 C.J. Stroud HOU QB 1 2
Deshaun Watson CLE QB 12 29 Bryce Young CAR QB 1 2
Anthony Richardson IND QB 12 29 Baker Mayfield TB QB 1 2
Tua Tagovailoa MIA QB 12 29 Zach Wilson NYJ QB 1 2
Kirk Cousins MIN QB 9 22 Desmond Ridder ATL QB 1 2
Dak Prescott DAL QB 8 21 Kyler Murray ARI QB 1 1
Daniel Jones NYG QB 8 21 Ryan Tannehill TEN QB 1 1
Jared Goff DET QB 8 20 Joshua Dobbs ARI QB 1 1
Derek Carr NO QB 8 20 Aidan O’Connell LV QB 1 1
Geno Smith SEA QB 8 20 Jameis Winston NO QB 1 1
Brock Purdy SF QB 6 16

Quarterbacks Recap

Age doesn’t matter when it comes to the redraft fantasy football trade value chart. However, talent does. Just like on the dynasty chart, Patrick Mahomes is the number one quarterback on the list. Despite the Chiefs already starting the year slow, he’s a consistent fantasy football player. He’s followed by another player who had a slow start in Josh Allen. Still, Allen is normally a high-scoring quarterback in fantasy football due to his big arm and willingness to pick up yards with his feet.

Speaking of picking up yards with his feet, Lamar Jackson comes in at third. When you throw age to the side, he’s an excellent quarterback to lead your fantasy football team. The same is true for Jalen Hurts. Hurts finds some more success in the passing game than Lamar; however, they’re both great options. Finally, at number five is Justin Herbert and Trevor Lawrence. Both of these young gun-slingers are hungry to prove that they belong in the conversation of the top quarterbacks.

Running Backs

Player Team Position Trade Value Player Team Position Trade Value
Christian McCaffrey SF RB 76 Jamaal Williams NO RB 8
Austin Ekeler LAC RB 75 AJ Dillon GB RB 8
Tony Pollard DAL RB 52 Zach Charbonnet SEA RB 8
Nick Chubb CLE RB 52 Tyjae Spears TEN RB 8
Bijan Robinson ATL RB 51 Damien Harris BUF RB 7
Saquon Barkley NYG RB 50 Antonio Gibson WAS RB 7
Josh Jacobs LV RB 49 Joshua Kelley LAC RB 6
Travis Etienne Jr. JAC RB 37 Gus Edwards BAL RB 6
Derrick Henry TEN RB 37 D’Andre Swift PHI RB 6
Joe Mixon CIN RB 37 De’Von Achane MIA RB 5
Rhamondre Stevenson NE RB 37 Tank Bigsby JAC RB 5
Aaron Jones GB RB 29 Chuba Hubbard CAR RB 4
Breece Hall NYJ RB 27 Elijah Mitchell SF RB 4
Jahmyr Gibbs DET RB 27 Zack Moss IND RB 4
Najee Harris PIT RB 26 Jerome Ford CLE RB 4
Kenneth Walker III SEA RB 26 Kendre Miller NO RB 3
James Cook BUF RB 20 Jerick McKinnon KC RB 3
Jonathan Taylor IND RB 20 Clyde Edwards-Helaire KC RB 3
Dameon Pierce HOU RB 20 Jeff Wilson Jr. MIA RB 3
Rachaad White TB RB 20 Justice Hill BAL RB 3
Miles Sanders CAR RB 20 Ezekiel Elliott NE RB 3
Alvin Kamara NO RB 19 Ty Chandler MIN RB 2
David Montgomery DET RB 16 Deon Jackson IND RB 2
Alexander Mattison MIN RB 16 Devin Singletary HOU RB 2
Javonte Williams DEN RB 15 Evan Hull IND RB 1
James Conner ARI RB 15 Sean Tucker TB RB 1
Isiah Pacheco KC RB 15 Kareem Hunt FA RB 1
Khalil Herbert CHI RB 15 Rashaad Penny PHI RB 1
Kenneth Gainwell PHI RB 15 Rico Dowdle DAL RB 1
Tyler Allgeier ATL RB 12 Mike Boone HOU RB 1
Brian Robinson Jr. WAS RB 12 Michael Carter NYJ RB 1
Dalvin Cook NYJ RB 12 DeeJay Dallas SEA RB 1
Cam Akers LAR RB 11 Boston Scott PHI RB 1
Kyren Williams LAR RB 9 Latavius Murray BUF RB 1
Raheem Mostert MIA RB 9 Chris Evans CIN RB 1
Samaje Perine DEN RB 9 Brandon Bolden LV RB 1
Jaylen Warren PIT RB 8 Kenny McIntosh SEA RB 1
Roschon Johnson CHI RB 8

Running Backs Recap

There’s no secret that when healthy, Christian McCaffrey is the best running back in the league. He’s versatile, contributing in the running and passing game, and a top-tier talent. In redraft, you can’t think of age or injury history. You just have to think of the now. Through Week 1, he had one of the best games of all running backs and is at the top of the running back fantasy football trade value chart for redraft. He’s tied for top on the entire chart with a wide receiver.

So far, through one week, we’ve seen some great performances and some duds as well. Even though he’ll likely miss Week 2, Austin Ekeler lands at the second spot for the redraft trade chart. Like CMC, Ekeler contributes in both the run and passing game. Tony Pollard also looked good, even though it was only one week, and they had a large lead. We’ll have to see what he continues doing when the games are tougher, but he looks to be a great fantasy football piece this year.

Pollard is tied with Chubb, who is one of the best pure running backs in the league. We refer to him as a grown-ass man on Old-Fashioned Football, and when you watch him play, you can see why. He’s a hard runner who is comfortable juking or running you over. The same can be said for rookie Bijan Robinson, who makes his first appearance on the redraft fantasy football trade value chart. Bijan looked the part in Week 1 and is likely to continue to get the ball put in his hands.

underdog fantasy deposit bonus

Wide Receivers

Player Team Position Trade Value Player Team Position Trade Value
Tyreek Hill MIA WR 76 Marvin Mims Jr. DEN WR 6
Justin Jefferson MIN WR 74 Rashod Bateman BAL WR 5
Amon-Ra St. Brown DET WR 50 Rashee Rice KC WR 5
Ja’Marr Chase CIN WR 50 Skyy Moore KC WR 5
A.J. Brown PHI WR 50 Quentin Johnston LAC WR 5
Stefon Diggs BUF WR 38 Treylon Burks TEN WR 5
Calvin Ridley JAC WR 38 Darnell Mooney CHI WR 4
CeeDee Lamb DAL WR 37 Allen Lazard NYJ WR 4
Davante Adams LV WR 36 Odell Beckham Jr. BAL WR 4
Brandon Aiyuk SF WR 29 Jameson Williams DET WR 4
Chris Olave NO WR 28 Tyler Boyd CIN WR 2
DeVonta Smith PHI WR 28 Adam Thielen CAR WR 2
Keenan Allen LAC WR 28 Jonathan Mingo CAR WR 2
Garrett Wilson NYJ WR 28 Van Jefferson LAR WR 2
DK Metcalf SEA WR 27 Michael Gallup DAL WR 2
Jaylen Waddle MIA WR 27 Marquez Valdes-Scantling KC WR 2
Amari Cooper CLE WR 26 Tutu Atwell LAR WR 2
Tee Higgins CIN WR 26 K.J. Osborn MIN WR 1
Deebo Samuel SF WR 21 Isaiah Hodgins NYG WR 1
DeAndre Hopkins TEN WR 20 Kadarius Toney KC WR 1
Zay Flowers BAL WR 20 Kendrick Bourne NE WR 1
Christian Watson GB WR 20 DeVante Parker NE WR 1
Mike Evans TB WR 20 Darius Slayton NYG WR 1
DJ Moore CHI WR 20 Donovan Peoples-Jones CLE WR 1
Chris Godwin TB WR 20 Robert Woods HOU WR 1
Drake London ATL WR 19 Josh Reynolds DET WR 1
Tyler Lockett SEA WR 19 Allen Robinson II PIT WR 1
Michael Pittman Jr. IND WR 16 Trey Palmer TB WR 1
Jahan Dotson WAS WR 16 Curtis Samuel WAS WR 1
Mike Williams LAC WR 15 Demario Douglas NE WR 1
Jordan Addison MIN WR 14 Braxton Berrios MIA WR 1
George Pickens PIT WR 14 Justin Watson KC WR 1
Christian Kirk JAC WR 14 Rondale Moore ARI WR 1
Terry McLaurin WAS WR 14 Brandon Johnson DEN WR 1
Cooper Kupp LAR WR 14 Mack Hollins ATL WR 1
Puka Nacua LAR WR 12 Tank Dell HOU WR 1
Courtland Sutton DEN WR 11 Josh Downs IND WR 1
Jerry Jeudy DEN WR 11 Noah Brown HOU WR 1
Jaxon Smith-Njigba SEA WR 11 Samori Toure GB WR 1
Elijah Moore CLE WR 11 Laviska Shenault Jr. CAR WR 1
Diontae Johnson PIT WR 11 Tyler Scott CHI WR 1
Marquise Brown ARI WR 11 Quez Watkins PHI WR 1
Brandin Cooks DAL WR 10 Terrace Marshall Jr. CAR WR 1
Gabe Davis BUF WR 10 Erik Ezukanma MIA WR 1
Jakobi Meyers LV WR 9 Kalif Raymond DET WR 1
Zay Jones JAC WR 9 Deonte Harty BUF WR 1
Michael Thomas NO WR 8 Michael Wilson ARI WR 1
Nico Collins HOU WR 8 DeAndre Carter LV WR 1
Romeo Doubs GB WR 8 Marquise Goodwin CLE WR 1
JuJu Smith-Schuster NE WR 8 Cedrick Wilson Jr. MIA WR 1
Rashid Shaheed NO WR 6 Devin Duvernay BAL WR 1
Jayden Reed GB WR 6

Wide Receivers Recap

Justin Jefferson was the top receiver on the dynasty fantasy football trade value chart. However, he’s currently sitting at second on the redraft. This may change as the season progresses, though. However, through one week of play, it’s hard not to say Tyreek Hill sits atop the wide receivers and maybe even the league. He’s uncoverable, he’s fast, and he’s going to keep racking up yards this year.

Next is a three-way tie between Amon Ra St. Brown, Ja’Marr Chase, and AJ Brown. All three of these receivers have shown a great connection with their quarterbacks and may flip-flop all year with which one is the better option. St. Brown and Goff built a great connection last year and already look to be on the same page this year. On the other hand, AJ Brown was seen frustrated with Jalen Hurts in last night’s game against the Vikings due to limited targets.

Ja’Marr Chase and the Bengals had a rough first week against the Browns. However, look for them to bounce back. Chase is still one of the top receivers in the league, and I wouldn’t be hitting that panic button quite yet.

Tight Ends

Player Team Position Trade Value Player Team Position Trade Value
Travis Kelce KC TE 48 Dawson Knox BUF TE 2
Mark Andrews BAL TE 35 Logan Thomas WAS TE 2
T.J. Hockenson MIN TE 27 Irv Smith Jr. CIN TE 1
Darren Waller NYG TE 21 Tyler Conklin NYJ TE 1
George Kittle SF TE 15 Donald Parham Jr. LAC TE 1
Dallas Goedert PHI TE 15 Harrison Bryant CLE TE 1
Evan Engram JAC TE 12 Kylen Granson IND TE 1
Kyle Pitts ATL TE 11 Durham Smythe MIA TE 1
Tyler Higbee LAR TE 11 Adam Trautman DEN TE 1
David Njoku CLE TE 11 Mike Gesicki NE TE 1
Dalton Kincaid BUF TE 11 Noah Gray KC TE 1
Pat Freiermuth PIT TE 8 Zach Ertz ARI TE 1
Sam LaPorta DET TE 8 Josh Oliver MIN TE 1
Luke Musgrave GB TE 8 Will Dissly SEA TE 1
Hunter Henry NE TE 6 Brock Wright DET TE 1
Hayden Hurst CAR TE 6 Trey McBride ARI TE 1
Juwan Johnson NO TE 6 Austin Hooper LV TE 1
Dalton Schultz HOU TE 6 Greg Dulcich DEN TE 1
Cole Kmet CHI TE 5 Cole Turner WAS TE 1
Chigoziem Okonkwo TEN TE 5 Jordan Akins CLE TE 1
Gerald Everett LAC TE 4 Cade Otton TB TE 1
Jake Ferguson DAL TE 4

Tight Ends Recap

Which age thrown out of the formulas on the redraft version of the fantasy football trade value chart, Travis Kelce is top of the charts in a big way. He’s hands down the top fantasy football tight end in the league. In fact, when looking at the values, he’s 13 points ahead of Mark Andrews, the second tight end. Both of these guys were held out in Week 1 due to injury, yet both find themselves on the top of the list still.

Behind them is T.J. Hockenson, who had a big Week 2 already. He’s a playmaker and a matchup nightmare for opposing defenses. The same can be said for the guy in fifth place, George Kittle. Both former Iowa tight ends, Kittle and Hockenson, can bring a lot of value. Kittle’s toughest part has been staying healthy.

At fourth is Darren Waller. Talent has never been a question for Waller. Health has been a bit of a question more often recently. However, after getting out of Vegas and off the Raiders, Waller has a fresh start with the Giants. Waller could end up leading this team in receiving. I wouldn’t worry about him just yet, but maybe you can trade for him relatively cheap.

Related Content

Sports Gambling Podcast

MLB Gambling Podcast

NBA Gambling Podcast

Hockey Gambling Podcast

NFL Gambling Podcast


audio podcasts like homepage (post masonry grid, category: NFL)

video podcasts like homepage (post grid, category: NFL)

Game of the Week: Kansas Jayhawks at Texas Longhorns | The Big 12 College Experience (Ep. 35)

NFL Week Two

NFL Week Three

NFL Week Four

NFL Week Five

audio podcasts like homepage (post grid, category: NFL)